Elsevier

Cognitive Psychology

Volume 132, February 2022, 101444
Cognitive Psychology

Robust priors for regularized regression

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cogpsych.2021.101444Get rights and content
Under a Creative Commons license
Open access

Highlights

Zero as a prior in penalized regression can be improved upon.

Priors for regularized regression can be sourced from human decision heuristics.

Heuristics selectively discard information like covariance between cues.

These priors are simple, robust, interpretable and work well across domains.

Our approach extends to the analysis of brain imaging data as well.

Abstract

Induction benefits from useful priors. Penalized regression approaches, like ridge regression, shrink weights toward zero but zero association is usually not a sensible prior. Inspired by simple and robust decision heuristics humans use, we constructed non-zero priors for penalized regression models that provide robust and interpretable solutions across several tasks. Our approach enables estimates from a constrained model to serve as a prior for a more general model, yielding a principled way to interpolate between models of differing complexity. We successfully applied this approach to a number of decision and classification problems, as well as analyzing simulated brain imaging data. Models with robust priors had excellent worst-case performance. Solutions followed from the form of the heuristic that was used to derive the prior. These new algorithms can serve applications in data analysis and machine learning, as well as help in understanding how people transition from novice to expert performance.

Keywords

Decision making
fMRI
Heuristics
Inductive bias
Inference
Robust priors

Data and materials availability

1. The 20 datasets from Application I can be retrieved from: https://osf.io/fg4p5/ 2. The Breast Cancer Wisconsin (Diagnostic) Data Set from Application II can be retrieved from: https://archive.ics.uci.edu/ml/datasets/Breast+Cancer+Wisconsin+(Diagnostic) 3. Code and data for Applications I and II can be found at: https://github.com/bobaseb/robustpriorsregression 4. Code for the simulations of the brain imaging data can be found at a fork of the RSA Toolbox (Nili et al. 2014) (develop branch): https://github.com/bobaseb/rsatoolboxlss/tree/develop/LSSproject